The buzz going around is that Intuit’s TurboTax installs spyware that doesn’t allow you to pirate a copy of TurboTax, and as a result can cause the software to stop functioning even if you’ve done nothing wrong (here and here and here for more info).
This might cause some to consider TaxCut. I will recount for you my experience with TaxCut from last year.
Around the beginning of 2002 I started thinking about how I would do my taxes, 2001 being the first year that I made enough money to be taxed. The hip thing to do seemed to be to use TurboTax but no, I wanted to be a little different. A little hipper a cat than the rest. Considering a glowing Macworld review and a $10 cheaper pricetag, I bought TaxCut.
What a steaming pile of vomit it was. One of its big highlights was being “The First OS X native tax program!” Apparently the programmers didn’t have a working copy of OS X or any Macintosh whatsoever to test it on. It felt like a bunch of Mac hating PC nerds bought a copy of some O’Reilly “Carbon is Easy!” book, slopped some code together and sent it directly to the duplication house. There was no way this software had been beta tested. This was pure prerelease alpha.
Every interface element was drawn incorrectly. Clicking a radio button, for example, moved said radio button about a centimeter to the left and drew it in a completely different style and size (covering important text while it was at it). Tabbing from field to field didn’t work. Oh, and also, it notoriously crashed. About halfway through a section, it would just *blink* disappear. Crashed. Ho ho! No autosave feature either! Another cool feature was that every time I saved, a save dialog came up. Typically this is only needed after the first time, but no, good ol’ TaxCut let me choose a new name and destination each time. Yay! (and yes, I’d have to tell it to replace the old one).
The funness continues! Once you’re done with the tax form, TaxCut checks it for errors. Oh, it would show you where the errors were all right. But you couldn’t change them! No matter how many times I entered a value into the “2001 income” field, it would forget it. Maybe if it were “business expenses” or “property taxes” I could have let it just slide, but my feeling was that the IRS probably cared to know my annual income.
Mind you I was using the most up-to-date version on April 14th. Finally I said “Fuck You” to TaxCut, kicked something and used Ellie’s PC running TurboTax to flawlessly complete my taxes in about 30 minutes.
So I don’t know where that leaves me now. I certainly won’t ever buy TaxCut again (and I urge you to avoid it as well) no matter how good they may make the 2003 version. I don’t like the idea of spyware, though perhaps this might be a case where Mac software negligence becomes a benefit (does the spyware app run on a Mac?)
No, this year I will pay someone to do my taxes. Though I don’t believe I should have to pay anything to do my taxes. If the government feels it necessary to take my money without asking, they should cover any expenses incurred in completing them. “Why don’t you just do them yourself?” The idea of spending even a second figuring out how much money the US government should steal from me this year makes me nauseous.
Tags: computers